Find checks and audits of research papers
Look up a paper to see what other people and tools have checked, what they found, and how they did it.
A small, growing collection. Public checks are free to browse, with no account needed.
Search by title, author, DOI or PMID, or browse the available checks.
Title and author search covers six starter papers and any additional listed papers with verified metadata. DOI and PMID lookups match the submitted identifier. A missing check does not mean a paper passed.
Bring scattered audits together
Paper checks are spread across websites, tools and research projects. Find existing work in one place, follow the original report, and see what has already been examined before starting another audit.
Keep sources and methods visible
Look for the person, tool or model behind a report, the method it used, and the material it examined. That context helps people compare approaches and give credit to the work behind them.
How Evidence Guide worksEvidence Guide collects reports. Inclusion does not mean a finding has been independently verified.
Examples of paper audits
Audits can examine different parts of a paper. Browse the collection to see which types are currently represented.
- Citation checks
- Examining a paper’s references and the claims made about them.
- Statistical recalculations
- Checking reported numbers against the stated calculations.
- Image checks
- Looking for issues such as duplicated or altered figures.
- Computational reruns
- Rerunning an analysis to examine how its results were produced.
Producing paper checks? Read the contribution docs for submitting documented records with an authorized account.